Binding Arbitration Agreements


This case is not an anomaly. Rather, it reflects existing arbitration law and illustrates the difficulties ordinary workers face in trying to enforce their legal labour rights. Below we present the applicable arbitration law and then present data on the extent of the use of arbitration and the impact of arbitration on the ability of workers and consumers to assert their rights. The stated purpose of New York and federal law was to make written conciliation agreements enforceable. The main provision of the federal law, which was copied from the New York Statute, was Section 2, which made “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable written conciliation agreements in contracts that involve commerce, unless there are legal or cheap reasons to revoke a contract.” 6 Other sections of the Act contained a mandatory stay of judicial proceedings and an obligation for courts to order the parties if the parties to the dispute had a written arbitration agreement. The FAA has also provided for judicial enforcement of arbitral awards and has established extremely narrow grounds for a court to refuse to do so. The image of arbitration as a creature of the unionized workplace began to shift when the Supreme Court, in its 1991 Gilmer decision, which was debated above, began allowing legal labor rights to submit arbitration agreements. 2304, a anti-dominant proceeding in which the Supreme Court ruled that a waiver of class actions in an arbitration clause could be enforced despite the high cost of bringing an individual action. In this case, Scalia J.A., who argued for the majority, wrote that “the fact that it is not worth the cost of proving a legal remedy does not constitute the elimination of the right to pursue that appeal.” Based on this precedent, the Court of Appeal denied Ms. Sutherland the right to collectively bring her dispute before a court or arbitration proceeding, effectively eliminating her right to overtime pay under federal law. No no. Voluntary arbitration procedures have been used for years in commercial disputes. Companies have set up panels of arbitrators experienced in the sector or in the field to settle issues quickly and cheaply in the event of a dispute between them.

36. Although there is no public register of all companies that require mandatory arbitration of their employees, the disclosure statements that arbitration service providers must publish contain the names of the companies concerned. The most comprehensive and comprehensive case information currently available is from the American Arbitration Association: www.adr.org/aaa/faces/aoe/gc/consumer. The Ninth Circle applied california`s three-way test, which finds that a class action waiver in a consumer contract is not applicable if (1) the agreement is a contract of adhesion – that is: A form contract submitted by a powerful party of a weaker party on a take-it-or-leave-it basis, (2) the dispute likely involves small amounts of compensation, and (3) the party with superior bargaining power has implemented a scheme to intentionally defraud a large number of consumers for small amounts of individual money…

   Send article as PDF